America Argues
Sports4d ago · 9 comments

With the Commanders' new stadium deal in the mix, should Ashburn sports fans finally shift their primary loyalty away from DC's other teams?

The Commanders practice facility put Ashburn on the NFL map, yet plenty of locals still bleed Caps or Nationals red. In a town this close to the action, can you really claim to be a true Ashburn sports fan without riding with the Commanders first?

Join the debate to comment

Reading is free. Members pay to post — that's why it stays clean.

Add your comment

9 comments

  • Yuki4d ago

    Born and raised in Ashburn. My dad took me to my first Redskins — yes, REDSKINS — game at RFK when I was seven years old. You don't just "shift loyalty" because some stadium deal gets announced. That's not how fandom works. That's not how ANY of this works.

  • Casey3d ago

    My neighbor literally has a Capitals flag, a Commanders flag, AND an Arsenal flag all on the same pole outside his house. I think that man is doing it right. Why is this even a competition? We're not choosing a religion here people.

  • Zara R.4d ago

    The Commanders haven't won anything meaningful in decades. You want me to make them my PRIMARY team over the Caps, who actually brought home a Cup in 2018? Hard disagree. Wake me up when Washington wins a Super Bowl.

  • Leo3d ago

    I'll shift my loyalty to the Commanders the moment they show ANY loyalty to this fanbase. Dan Snyder spent two decades treating us like ATMs and the new ownership hasn't exactly set the world on fire yet. The idea that geography should determine who I root for is honestly a little insulting. I grew up watching Ovechkin. That's not going anywhere because a stadium might get built near a toll road.

  • Jordan4d ago

    I think people are missing the real point here. The stadium deal, if it actually goes through — and that's a BIG if given how many times this franchise has fumbled off the field — could genuinely transform northern Virginia's identity as a sports hub. Ashburn specifically stands to benefit economically in ways that go beyond just fandom. So yes, maybe it's time locals started treating the Commanders less like a disappointing uncle and more like a genuine cornerstone of community identity. That said, nobody's telling me to stop loving my Nats.

  • Ravi T.3d ago

    To everyone defending the Caps and Nats — genuine challenge: when's the last time you actually drove into DC for a game vs. just watching from your couch? Because if the answer is "a while," maybe the real issue is that Ashburn needs its OWN venue, and the Commanders stadium could finally be that. Stop treating this like betrayal and start treating it like an upgrade for the whole community.

  • Priya4d ago

    Fun fact: the Commanders practice facility has actually been in Ashburn since 1999. So this "Commanders put Ashburn on the map" thing is a bit late, don't you think? We've been on the map for 25 years lol. The stadium deal doesn't suddenly make us a football town.

  • Reese 924d ago

    ok so genuine question for the people who've lived here longer than me (moved from Chicago two years ago) — does the practice facility actually bring any real energy to the area or is it just like a corporate campus that happens to have football players in it? asking because i drive past it on my way to work and it always seems... quiet?

  • Casey T.3d ago

    Nope. Hard disagree. I cheer for whoever's winning.

More debates people can't stop arguing about