When a single cycling class costs $40 and your gym membership signals your income bracket, is the city's wellness culture actually about health — or just another way to perform wealth?
Join the debate to comment
Reading is free. Members pay to post — that's why it stays clean.
Add your commentborn and raised in the Bronx. we didn't have boutique fitness studios growing up. we had concrete and stairs and labor. my uncle worked construction his whole life and had arms that looked like a anatomy textbook illustration. wellness culture in Manhattan is rich people reinventing things poor people have always done out of necessity and then charging each other $45 to access it through an app.
I paid $38 for a SoulCycle class in 2019, cried a little on the bike, and never went back. Not because of the price — because the instructor kept yelling at us about our 'authentic selves' while I was just trying to burn off a dollar slice. The whole thing felt like a TED talk with pedals.
Somewhat related — has anyone else noticed that the language around this stuff has gotten completely unhinged? I got an email from a local studio last week describing a Tuesday morning barre class as a 'radical act of self-sovereignty.' It's BARRE. You hold a wooden rail and do small leg lifts. I'm not trying to diminish anyone's workout but the wellness-speak industrial complex is a whole separate problem from the pricing.
The real issue nobody mentions: these boutique places actually WORK for getting people to show up consistently. The accountability, the community, the instructors who know your name — that stuff has real psychological value. Telling people to just jog in the park sounds logical until you remember that almost nobody actually does it long-term. Sometimes you pay for the structure, not the squat rack.
My building in Astoria has a gym in the basement. Treadmill, some free weights, a stationary bike. Costs nothing extra. You know who uses it? Me and one older guy named Gerald who watches Fox News while doing calf raises. Meanwhile people are taking out what amounts to a car payment to go sweat in a candlelit room in Nolita. I just... I cannot.
Honestly? Yes. I grew up in Flushing and my parents stayed fit by walking everywhere and doing tai chi in the park for FREE. Now I live in Williamsburg and my coworkers talk about their Equinox memberships like its a personality trait. $300 a month so you can say you go to Equinox. Thats not health thats a status symbol with a towel service.
SoulCycle was absolutely founded in New York, not Chicago. Elizabeth Cutler and Julie Rice started it on the Upper West Side in 2006. Please don't spread misinformation on a topic people are actually trying to discuss seriously.
Hard disagree with the framing here. Nobody complains that a nice restaurant makes food 'elitist.' Boutique studios exist in a market. If you want free fitness, Central Park exists. The West Side Highway path exists. The NYCHA gyms exist. Stop acting like Barry's Bootcamp is blocking your access to a jumping jack.
the class signal thing goes both ways tho. i work at a boutique studio front desk (not gonna say which one) and we have members who i KNOW are stretching their budgets to be here because the social belonging matters to them as much as the workout. its not always rich people performing wealth. sometimes its regular people spending money they maybe shouldnt because they finally found somewhere that makes them feel like they belong. that part of the conversation always gets lost.
I want someone to genuinely answer this: how many of you dunking on boutique fitness in this thread have tried it more than twice? Because I was a skeptic too. Then a friend dragged me to a Pilates reformer class in Chelsea and I fixed a back problem I'd had for three years that two different physical therapists couldn't crack. Context matters. Cost matters. But so does what actually works for YOUR body.
just moved here from Columbus six months ago and i genuinely cannot believe what people pay for these classes. like i found a perfectly good YMCA on 14th street and people look at me like im describing a soup kitchen. the fitness hierarchy in this city is REAL and it is BIZARRE
Fun fact: SoulCycle was actually founded in Chicago and later expanded to NYC, which is why the culture there is so different from what you see here.
Is it wrong to choose not to have children just because you don't want to?
110 comments
Would you still eat meat if you had to kill the animal yourself?
109 comments
Is judging someone by their height as shallow as judging by their weight?
108 comments
Are dating apps genuinely harder for men or for women?
108 comments