Long-timers in Brooklyn, Queens, and the Bronx argue that Manhattan has become a sanitized theme park for the ultra-wealthy, while Manhattan defenders say the island is still the cultural engine of the city. Who's right?
Join the debate to comment
Reading is free. Members pay to post — that's why it stays clean.
Add your commentMy grandmother ran a laundromat on Dyckman Street in upper Manhattan for 22 years and raised four kids in a two-bedroom walkup. That building sold last year for something obscene and the new owners turned her old unit into an 'executive short-term rental.' So yeah. Ask me again if Manhattan is real New York. Ask my grandmother.
The Bronx invented hip hop. Brooklyn had the Harlem Renaissance spillover, the jazz clubs, Biggie, Bed-Stuy's entire cultural legacy. Queens gave the world Nas, A Tribe Called Quest, and the best food scene on the eastern seaboard. What did Manhattan 'invent' lately? The $28 avocado toast? I'll wait.
Born and raised in Sunnyside, Queens. Spent 38 years watching Manhattan slowly become a giant mall with apartments. You want real New York? Come to Jackson Heights on a Tuesday night. Come to Flushing. Come to Fordham Road. Manhattan is a postcard. We're the actual city.
Fun fact for the people saying Manhattan lost its soul — the Lower East Side has been 'dying' since literally 1987. I have newspaper clippings. My uncle has newspaper clippings. Every single generation says this. Manhattan reinvents itself. That IS the New York identity.
Hard disagree. Lincoln Center, the Met, Carnegie Hall, Broadway, the Village — all still there, all still world-class. The 'real New York' argument from outer borough people is just gentrification guilt deflection. Queens has its OWN luxury condos now if you haven't noticed.
Respectfully, the Harlem Renaissance was centered IN HARLEM, which is IN MANHATTAN. People keep saying Manhattan has no culture like they forget Harlem exists the second it's convenient for their argument. The outer boroughs are great but let's not rewrite history here.
i moved here from Ohio two years ago and settled in Astoria and honestly manhattan feels like a different city to me whenever i go. like a very expensive version of Times Square that just keeps going. my neighborhood has bodegas and old greek men playing backgammon outside and a guy who fixes shoes out of a cart. thats what i thought new york was supposed to be
Grew up on City Island in the Bronx, left for fifteen years, came back in 2019. Honestly both things are true simultaneously and the debate itself is exhausting. Manhattan sets the agenda culturally and financially, outer boroughs actually live it on the ground. You need both. A city isn't one neighborhood. Can we stop pretending there's a winner here?
Is it wrong to choose not to have children just because you don't want to?
110 comments
Would you still eat meat if you had to kill the animal yourself?
109 comments
Is judging someone by their height as shallow as judging by their weight?
108 comments
Are dating apps genuinely harder for men or for women?
108 comments